Five Guys Burgers Vs. In N Out. Is There Really Any Comparison For Best Burger?

five guys vs. in-n-out burger

Mmmhmm. This is a tasty burger.

That memorable phrase was uttered by Samuel Jackson in the cult classic Pulp Fiction as he was chowing down on a Big Kahuna burger.

There’s a certain stigma for a restaurant having the title of “Best Burger” and rightfully so.  Nothing beats a good burger.  Nothing. My mouth is watering now just thinking about it. Seriously….. I’m actually drooling.  Okay, I’m out of my burger trance….for now.

When I think of the “best burger”, there’s only one that comes to mind.  Any guesses?

Let me give you one little hint:

In-N-Out Burger

Still not sure?   Okay, maybe one more clue:

In N Out Burger Time!

In case you haven’t figured it out yet, it’s no In-N-Out Burger.   If you’ve never been to the blog (shame on you), then you don’t know about my completely healthy attraction obsession with the West Coast burger ‘chain.

How obsessed?   Read this article where I share my undying love for In-N-Out.

When people tell me that they don’t like In-N-Out, I take it personally as if they’re insulting my Filipino mother’s cooking – don’t mess with momma!

I don’t know why exactly.  I just know I love it so much and can’t imagine why anybody else wouldn’t love it, too.

Have I mentioned how good it is yet?

Want to see my quick reaction video to Five Guys Vs. In-N-Out? If you have patience, keep scrolling down.

Five Who?

A couple years ago I kept hearing about this new burger chain that was a serious contender for best burger.  Initially, I thought, “Yeah, right. In their dreams“.

But the talk didn’t go away.   This “so called best burger joint” is called Five Guys.   Originating out of Virginia in 1986 this burger joint has blown up.  They now have over 770 locations in the U.S. and are scheduled to open 200 more in Southern California alone.  Yes, they are invading In-N-Out’s backyard.

Let the battle begin.

Coming to Town

Five Guys opened a location in Fairview Heights (suburb of St. Louis) and I should have been eager to try it just to see what it’s all about.  But I couldn’t bring myself to do it as I felt like I was cheating on my wife.  It just felt wrong.   My wife wanted to try it so she took our 3 kids in and ordered while I went next door and got Qdoba (Mexican fast food joint) and brought it inside Five Guys to eat.  That was for you In-N-Out.  I’ll show them :)

I never really knew if I would go back to Five Guys.  I was content knowing that know one could dethrone In-N-Out in my mind.   Then I happened across the article on the Huffington Post that claimed to a survey by Zagat in 2010, that Five Guys had bested In-N-Out for “best fast food burger”.   Recount I say!

If you dig a little deeper into the survey, you’ll see that the survey was not weighted for number of locations and was more based on total reach.  This is significant in that Five Guys has almost 3 times more locations.  Nonetheless, this was a wake up call for me and I realized that I had avoided the inevitable for too long.  It was time to try Five Guys.

My Visit to Five Guys

Five Guys Burger and Fries
After a family trip to the St. Louis Zoo, the stage was set.  I was finally to give this In-N-Out wannabe a chance to prove themselves.   Accompanied with my Canon Rebel and heft appetite, I entered and photographed my experience.

IMG_6502

Five Guys Colors

When you first enter a Five Guys restaurant, the first thing that struck me the colors of red and white.  Hmmm……wonder where I’ve seen that before. <cough>Copy cat<cough>.  There was a brief moment that I felt like it was a dream and that I had mistakenly walked into an In-N-Out and I was getting ready to sink my teeth into a juicy Double-Double.  Unfortunately not.

IMG_6503

Five Guys Menu

Other similarities are found in their menu.   As you can see their main focus is fresh burgers and fries; although they do offer bacon cheeseburgers and “Little” versions of all the burgers.  Other noticeable differences were they offered hot dogs.  While the cheese dog sounded tempting, I was here for one thing and one thing only:  a burger.

Five Guys Burger and fries Menus and Prices

Another difference is that they offer a Veggie sandwich and a grilled cheese.  While In-N-Out doesn’t have this on their main menu, it can be found on their secret menu.   Bet you didn’t know that did you? ;-)

Five Guys Burgers Vs. In N Out

The biggest noticeable difference that caught my attention with the menu were the number of toppings that you could add to your burger – 15 in all.  According to the Five Guys website, there are over 250,000 ways to order a burger at their place.   Now that’s a lot of options.

Personally, I think it’s fluff.   A burger is a burger.   Meat, cheese, some ketchup will suffice.   Now you add some In-N-Out secret sauce and you just added a little bit of heaven.

Five Guys Prices

One noticeable difference with Five Guys was their prices.  I’m used to getting 3 cheeseburgers, fries and shake for less than ten bucks.   At Five Guys, a double cheeseburger, large fries and a drink was almost $12.  I don’t mind paying $5 for a good burger.  Don’t mind a bit.  I do think $4 and change for large fries is a bit much.

Get Your Peanuts

One coolness factor about Five Guys is that they give you free peanuts to munch on while you wait for your order.   Surprisingly the floor was pretty clean with no peanut shells in sight.

Five Guys Peanuts

Five Guys Propaganda

If there’s one thing about walking into a Five Guys restaurant, they are very proud of themselves.  They have signs everywhere touting how great they are.   Now I’m not going to fault them for that…..too bad.   But the signs are everywhere.  Take a look….

Five Guys Burgers Vs. In N Out

And some more…..

IMG_6506

And again…..

Five Guys Burger and Fries

They even had signs leading up to the bathroom.  Seriously.

Many signs boast “Best Burger”.  But it is true?

Let’s find out.

Five Guys Taste Test

After I received my order, it was finally time to sink my teeth and give Five Guys a true taste test.   First up, the fries.

Five Guys Fries

One neat thing about Five Guys fries is that you have the option to order regular fries or with Cajun seasoning.   I had a chance to try both and much more enjoyed the Cajun seasoning.  Overall, though; I was very unimpressed with the fries.   I even offered some to my three year old son who will eat McDonald’s fries like crack (seriously), but he took one bit and didn’t want them.  For my son to turn down french fries was just as surprising if you offered Charlie Sheen speed and he said no – it just doesn’t happen.

But it did.

Next up the burger.

Five Guys Burgers

Five Guys Burgers Vs. In N Out

When I first took the foil wrapped burger out of the brown paper bag, I wasn’t sure what to think.   The presentation was very poor and reminded me of something that I would get at a carnival or something.   But you can’t taste presentation, right?   It’s time to eat.

Five Guys Burgers Vs. In N OutLike tasting a fine wine for the first time, I first wanted to enjoy the aroma of the freshly unwrapped burger.   See, I’m not going to lie.  There’s part of me that wanted to really like this burger over In-N-Out.   Why you ask?   Easy…..it’s freaking closer to me and I can eat it more often!   I only get the luxury of having In-N-Out maybe once a year and; frankly, that is not enough.

So with great anticipation I sunk my teeth into my Five Guys double cheeseburger and, and, and………..

IMG_6529

……it’s a burger.   Nothing special.   Didn’t rock my world.  Actually, not even close.   All the hype. All the hoopla.   At the end of the day I had a $5 burger wrapped in foil that left me very unsatisfied.  Here’s my quick video reaction from the experience:

What was even funny about the experience is that the gal that took my order struck a conversation with me because I was taking pictures. She asked if I was a photographer – I guess for all the obsessive pictures I was taking :) I told her that I was actually doing a blog post comparing Five Guys to In-N-Out. What she said next floored me….

She told me that she had a cousin that lives in California and loves to visit them so she can have In-N-Out because she loves them. She went on to tell me that she loved them even better than Five Guys referring to their burgers as, “Ok”. Ha! Even one of their own knows the truth.

What do Others Say?

The whole experience left me bewildered so I decided to hit up some blogging friends on what they thought of the Five Guys vs. In-N-Out debate.  Here’s what some others had to say:

My boy Baker from Man Vs. Debt had this to say:

WOW – just today I had In and Out burger… (on my cheat day).

Just a Double Double – I was not impressed at all. Tomato was terrible and I had to take it off. Burger was o.k. but nothing special.

I have 5 guys in the south when we were going through – blew my mind. It was amazing.

The fries at In and Out were TERRIBLE. Neither Courtney, MILLIGAN, or I would eat them. A 3-year-old wouldn’t eat them. Think about that.

I didn’t have the shake either place – but I’d rate Five Guys a 9/10 – nearly perfect experience and taste.

In and Out was like a 5/10. Maybe slightly better than any other fast food joint. :(

Jeremy from Gen X Finance added:

Srsly. Some of the best burgers I’ve ever had were simply fresh ground beef with some salt and pepper. Kiss them with fire and there’s more flavor than any burger at any restaurant, chain or otherwise.

I’ve eaten a lot of burgers in my day, and my waistline can attest to that. But Five guys, Fudruckers, Fatburger, In N Out, or even the local hole in the wall that has admittedly decent burgers, nothing compares to a simple fresh homemade burger.

Doughroller offers:

The first Five Guys location is close to where we live here in Virginia. No place to sit. Just order your food and get out. One of the best burgers I’ve ever had. And the fries are incredible. We all have a favorites, but I’m surprised to hear such low opinions of Five Guys. Maybe I’m living in a cave, but nothing beats a Five Guys burger. And yes, I’ve had an In N Out burger. I thought it was fine, but nothing special.

Real Men Know Burgers

Wanting to get some more takes on the issue, I also hit up the Art of Manliness forums to see what other men thought about what the best burger was.   Here’s were some of the more memorable responses:

Just had In and Out for the first time a few weeks ago, felt it was highly overrated.  Sure it was a good tasty burger, just not near worth the hype. Down here in Texas it is Whataburger, that is where it is at.  Five Guys is a tasty burger, but I will still take Whataburger over it.

I agree, In-and-Out is overrated.  Had it for the first time (it’s new here in Utah) about three months ago.

Carl’s Jr. Guacamole burger gets my vote for best fast food burger.

Double Double with Cheese has my heart.

Literally.

Five Guys IS overrated. Since it’s the only chain mentioned here that happens to be in business in Colorado. . .we’re kind of deprived on the fast food burger front. Guess I’ll cast my vote for Freddy’s.

In n Out is fricking good. I always get 2 cheeseburgers with grilled onions and animal style fries on the side. Best on So Cal

Other great burgers are Guacamole Bacon from carls Jr, Hawaiian from Islands (has teriyaki sauce & pineapple), and Poli Bacon Chessburger from Pink’s (bacon cheeseburger with a butterflied polish sausage).

I worry Gov. Brown will revoke my Cal. residency, but I don’t like In-n-Out. I really like Five Guys, and am very happy they have come to Cal.

It seems to me Fuddruckers should be mentioned in this conversation, though I still prefer Five Guys.

Ooooh in-n-out hands down. The cold tomato and lettuce mixes with the warm patty and melted cheese is like food art. Then you have the option to add as many patties as you want.(I have single-handedly devoured a 10×10) If you want to enjoy a food poem go to in-n-out.

In-N-Out on Facebook

Lastly, I thought it would be neat to see what In-N-Out fans thought of the Five Guys vs. In-N-Out comparison.   I headed over the In-N-Out fan page on Facebook and take a poll to their 1.7 million fans.  In case you were curious, Five Guys only has 486,00.  The exact number is 1,281,936 more In-N-Out fans than Five Guys….but who’s counting :)

Anyway, here’s a screenshot of what some of the In-N-Out loyalists had to say:

In-N-Out Burger FacebookThere’s was actually a ton more comments, but I could only include so many.   If there’s one thing you can say about In-N-Out burger fans, they are extremely loyal.

In-N-Out.  You Had Me at Hello

In-N-Out is “The Burger” and will always be in my humble opinion which just happens to absolutely correct.   Now they just need to open some locations in the Midwest.   In-N-Out are you listening?    I need to have these people’s experience in the video below.  Check out the girl in the video.  I want to cry just like her.   Tears of In-N-Out joy……

What’s your favorite burger? Have you had a chance to try Five Guys or In-N-Out? I want to hear from you!

Related Posts with Thumbnails
Reports

Get the Money Dominating Toolkit

  • 6 Tools to Get Your Money Back on Track
  • The Ultimate Goal Achiever Workbook
  • 2 Free Chapters to my Best Selling Book
  • 21 Days to Destroy Your Bad Habits Worksheet

Comments | 17 Responses

  1. Danielle says

    You haven’t had anything until you come to the East coast and try Swensons burgers… I assure you, it would take the cake!

    I know some of you east coast (especially OHIOANS) would agree…!!!!

  2. says

    Yes, 5 Guys was the big rave about a year ago. I finally went and tried a burger and I had the same reaction as you. What was everyone talking about? The burger was so small. Sure you could add several patties, but it still didn’t enhance the taste. I found it to be much more greasy than an In-N-Out burger. I didn’t even like their fries. Since In-N-Out is closest to me, I’d probably still go there. But I think a Fuddruckers burger tops both. And what I think tops all is a dive called Best Burger. There are 2 in the Bay Area of CA, but I have no idea if there are any others.

  3. Chris Rowe says

    Best low price burger I have seen was the Burger King, buck double ($1.00) with the BK barbeque sauce and I would always ask for an onion ring (usually were given several for free) and it was like the old Burger King barbeque burger. No kidding, this was the best burger for the price. Also, the 5 Guy’s fries, while expensive are very good, cooked in Peanut Oil, worth mentioning as there are so many people with Peanut Alergies…it is well marked in the store, surprising me that you didn’t get a picture of that sign too.

  4. Jacki says

    In Canada, we have neither In-n-Out or Five Guys… all I know is that my mom went to a funeral in Conneticut in February, had a Five Guys burger and started talking about how “if she were younger, she’d buy a franshise and bring them here”. And this is from a woman who almost always passes on burgers.

  5. Jess says

    In-N-Out! I moved from LA to NYC a few years ago, and I miss In-N-Out, refuse to go to Five Guys… every time I visit LA, my first and last thing to do is to visit In-N-Out near LAX. Just thinking about it makes me drool now…

  6. Christy says

    In Idaho we don’t have In-n-out, but we have a look-alike “Burger Express” that was sued by In-n-out for looking so much like them inside & out.. 5 Guys is good when you get tired of having Burger King all the time, but BK is a better bang for buck… but I’ve heard good things about In-n-out so would like to taste sometime.

  7. Mark says

    Both places have mediocre burgers that are slightly better than McDonalds, I don’t see how you people think they are that good.

  8. Taka says

    The problem with comparing fast food is that they are never consistent even at their own location. Wendy’s food is different depending on what time of the day you go practically. Go close to lunch rushes and you’ve a good chance of getting the goods (hot crispy fries etc) but oftentimes you go and feel like you’ve licked a greasetrap. Likewise I’ve gone to five guys several times and while I’ve enjoyed each time there were definitely times when their burgers and fries were better than others. We don’t have in and out around here but I’ve read a bunch of these reviews and the descriptions of the burgers and services are rarely the same.

  9. Hailley says

    In east tn we don’t have an in-n-out that I know of but we do have a five guys about an hour away from where I live. It’s awesome. I can’t say it’s the best because I have never had ino, but it is far better than burger king, McDonald’s or any other cheapie fast food chain. There burgers are not good. Bk is good but not anywhere near 5 guys. The rest are awful. Whataburger is ok, as is fudruckers. The best (that I have tasted) fast food is five guys, and best sit down burger came from a place in Florida called fudpuckers not fudruckers. This was a sit down restaurant with a live alligator farm and a show. Amazing burgers. They had these awesome sweetbread buns and pineapple coleslaw on the side. Complimented so well according to my dad. I however don’t like coleslaw so I don’t know but the burger kicked butt!!

  10. lana says

    We moved from Charlotte (with 5 guys and no in and out) to AZ. AZ has both 5 guys and in and out, plus fat burger, heart attack burger and tons of others. I think they all do a good business with the 60K students at ASU.

    But, I have to say I like In and Out because of the employees, food, prices and the little Bible verses on the end of the cups.

    Some of the happiest employees in any corporation are In and Out. That says something. They are all cordial, clean cut and efficient.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>