I know that you were losing sleep because I had not written a post yet that outlines the differences between a 403(b) vs. 401(k). Oh wait….you weren’t?
I thought everybody was a retirement tax code freak like me. 😂
Either way, you or someone you know may have the option to fund a 403(b) and understanding how it compares to a 401(k) may prove to be helpful. When people are first hired into a full-time job and some part-time positions, they get handed a variety of paperwork and decisions they have to make right away as a new employee.
Among those items is the establishment of a company retirement account for their potential retirement savings from earnings.
The Difference between a 403b and a 401k
Most companies today offer employees a standard 401(k) retirement deferred savings plan. However, if a person works for the government or some organizations, like nonprofits, different options can come up, including the 403(b) plan. This raises the question of which is better between a 401(k) vs. 403(b).
A variety of retirement plans exist today, approved by the Internal Revenue Service as legal tax shelters for earnings. In almost all cases, except for a Roth IRA, the plans involve pre-tax income that is deferred to a holding account and allowed to gain profit and interest through compounding and investment.
When the funds are finally withdrawn, usually later in a person’s life, they should – in theory – be part of a larger retirement balance which can be used when a person is no longer working, ergo at a lower tax rate.
This maximizes the value of the dollars saved, even with inflation taken into account. Each of these plans has a numerical name, referring to the tax code statute that authorizes the activity and given plan.
The 401(k) Plan – The Basics
Most people know of or are familiar with the 401(k) retirement plan. But whether you are or you’re not, here are the plan highlights:
Income Tax Treatment. Contributions to a 401(k) plan are deductible from your taxable income in the year they are made. Investment earnings within the account accumulate on a tax-deferred basis.
Both contributions and investment earnings become taxable upon withdrawal and are added to your other income for the year that they are taken.
In this way you are shifting the tax burden from today until you retire, at which time you’ll presumably be in a lower tax bracket.
Contribution Limits. For 2019 the maximum contribution you can make to a 401(k) plan is $19,000, up $500 from last year. As the contribution limit rises, so does your investment potential. If you are age 50 or older, there is a catch-up provision of $6,000, enabling you to contribute a maximum of up to $24,500 per year.
Employer Matching Contributions. Employers can and often do match an employee’s contributions to a 401(k) plan. A typical match is 50% of the employee’s contribution, up to 6%, which means the employer contributes 3%, bringing the total contribution to 9%.
There is often a vesting period for the employer’s contribution, up to five years, after which the total amount of the employer’s contribution is considered “vested” by the employee (it’s then fully the employee’s money). In theory, an employer match – plus the maximum employee contribution – can be as high as $55,000 per year, which is the maximum contribution per employee under IRS regulations.
Withdrawal Requirements. You can begin taking withdrawals from your 401(k) plan once you reach age 59 1/2, and once again, those distributions will be added to your income for tax purposes. If you take withdrawals before turning 59 1/2, you will have to pay an early withdrawal penalty tax of 10% of the distribution, in addition to the regular tax liability that will be owed.
Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs). Like nearly every other type of retirement plan (except Roth IRAs), 401(k) plans require that you begin taking withdrawals from plan no later than when you reach age 70 1/2. If you don’t withdraw an RMD, don’t withdraw the full amount of the RMD, or don’t withdraw the RMD by the applicable deadline, the amount not withdrawn is taxed at 50%.
401(k) Loan Provisions. One of the benefits of a 401(k) is that you can take a loan against your account, as long as it is permitted by your employer (they aren’t legally obligated to do so). You can borrow out up to 50% of the plan value, up to a maximum of $50,000, and must repay the loan within five years.
However, if a 401(k) loan is taken for the purpose of purchasing the employee’s principal residence it can be paid back over a period of more than 5 years.
One thing to be aware of however is that if you leave your employer and you still have a loan balance outstanding, you must pay it back (within 60 days), otherwise it will be considered to be a distribution from the plan, and subject to regular income tax and, if you’re under age 59 1/2, the 10% early withdrawal penalty.
401(k) Portability and Rollover Provisions. If you leave your employer, you can take your 401(k) with you. You can then do a tax-free rollover either into the 401(k) plan of your new employer, a traditional IRA, a 457 plan, a SEP IRA, or a 403(b) plan. You may also rollover a 401(k) into a Roth IRA or a designated Roth that’s part of a traditional retirement plan (for example, a Roth 401(k) ), but the amount of the rollover will be subject to regular income tax in the year that the conversion is completed. (See IRS Rollover Chart for rollover summary details).
Note that rollovers can only be done after you’ve left the employer who sponsored the original 401(k) plan, and not while you are still employed.
401(k) Investment Options
Investment options in 401(k) plans run the gamut. In some plans, you may be limited to a half-dozen mutual funds or ETFs, and your employer’s company stock. In others, you’ll have as many options as the plan trustee has available.
For example, if the plan is held with Fidelity, chances are you’ll be picking from a selection of Fidelity funds. That will likely income a selection of target date funds. Blah! In case you didn’t know, I’m not a big fan of target date funds, but that’s a story for a different post.
The 403b Plan – The Basics
403(b) plans are very similar to 401(k) plans, except that where 401(k) plans are sponsored by for-profit businesses, 403(b) plans are for not-for-profit organizations that are tax-exempt under IRS Code 501(c)3. That includes educational institutions, school districts, governmental organizations, religious organizations, and hospitals.
- Income Tax Treatment. Same as for the 401(k) plan.
- Contribution Limits. Same as for the 401(k) plan, except for the maximum allowable contribution (MAC) provision below.
- Employer Matching Contributions. Same as for the 401(k) plan.
- Withdrawal Requirements. Same as for the 401(k) plan.
- Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs). Same as for the 401(k) plan, except that 403(b) plans have a special allowance for plans that received pre-1987 amounts. If so, then distributions are not required until December 31 of the year in which the plan participant turns age 75 or, if later, April 1 of the calendar year immediately following the calendar year in which the participant retires.
- 403(b) Loan Provisions. Same as for the 401(k) plan.
- 403(b) Portability and Rollover Provisions. Same as for the 401(k) plan, except that a 403(b) plan can also be rolled over into a 401(k) plan of a new employer.
Special MAC Rule with 403(b) Plans
Those with 15 years of service to an employer can then add another $3,000 to their annual contribution limit, depositing a potential $21,000 per year. This is called the maximum allowable contribution, or simply MAC.
Unfortunately, just because MAC is allowed under the IRS code does not mean the employer has to honor it. They have to include it in their plan document for it to go in effect. I had a client that met the 15-year requirement but since she was one of the only ones that did, her employer wasn’t aware of the MAC rule and didn’t feel the need to include it in their plan.
403(b) Investment Options
Most 403(b) plans provide a choice of mutual funds or annuities for the investment of saved funds. Ever since there was a shakeup in the 403(b) market a few years ago, I’ve seen quite a few mutual fund companies pull out. That means you’re seeing a lot more insurance companies offer some sort of annuity product in the plans. Personally, I’m not a big fan of this.
403(b) accounts typically appear in non-profit organizations, churches, school organizations, and government. There is a significant administrative difference from a 403(b) as eligible organizations have less paperwork to file with the IRS versus under a 401(k) plan.
Because the 403(b) plan is cheaper to administer as well, it’s favored by small entities with tight budgets but still wanting to offer workers a retirement perk.
Summary: 403(b) vs. 401(k)
Is one plan better than the other? In some respects, yes. But in most regards, they’re the same plan, with the 403(b) plan serving the same purpose for government and nonprofit employers that the 401(k) plan does for profit generating employers.
The two areas where the differences are the most significant are with investments and the MAC. Investment options are generally more numerous with 401(k) plans, particularly if the plan trustee is one of the major investment brokerage firms that offer something close to unlimited investment choices.
But the MAC provision is a definite plus in favor of the 403(b) plan. It enables long term employees to make higher contributions, even in addition to the catch-up provisions that are normally offered to participants who are age 50 or older.
Both plans offer employees a significant ability to shelter income from taxes and save for their retirement, regardless of the differences between the two.
In some cases, employers even provide a match to employees, depending on how much they deposit from their own money. This match is essentially free dollars everyone should take advantage of as much as possible when available.
That said, depending on the employer, a different plan type will be available. Few employers offer both types of accounts.
Tom says
You wrote:
Contribution Limits. For 2018 the maximum contribution you can make to a 401(k) plan is $18,500. If you are age 50 or older, there is a catch-up provision of $6,500, enabling you to contribute a maximum of up to $24,000 per year.
The catch up contribution is actually $6,000 which makes the total for someone over the age of 50 $24,500.
You also wrote:
In theory, an employer match – plus the maximum employee contribution – can be as high as $53,000 per year, which is the maximum contribution per employee under IRS regulations.
That IRS limit is actually $55,000.
-Tom
Jeff Rose says
Corrected, thanks Tom. No matter how much (or how many times) we edit, we still makes mistakes. Some of course are due to updated information in an older article like this one.
Aaron says
Also, i would of course contribute to my 403b and do have a employer contribution but not a match of 13.2 percent, I would probably put in 7% myself each month, but again should i build on the existing 401k balance and manage myself/or generic management option (BTW the 403b is still managed by Fidelity interestingly enough)
Jeff Rose says
Do you have an option to continue funding the 401k??? I thought it was disappearing in the merger?
Aaron says
Great write up very helpful…I have a question if you happen to monitor the comments here. I have a 401k managed by Fidelity for last 18 years, they provided an employee managed option and the funds have been doing great, but I suspect this is the case for most over the last 12 months as the market is doing great…that being said, my new employer has a 403b, which as I understand it has lower fees, however if i leave my 401k with fidelity, I am grandfathered in and they will continue to manage the fund distributions etc. However i can not contribute to it, they suggested a stay with them as its a decent amount and they probably want to keep the higher fees compared to that of the 403b. Anyways I am torn, should I transfer the fidelity managed with many more funds to my 403b which may have lower overall admin fees but fewer funds and they will not manage the contributions for optimal returns, I am pretty much stuck doing it myself or picking a fairly generic 403b fund management option….appreciate your response!
Jeff Rose says
Hi Aaron – This is really a matter of personal opinion. I like the greater investment options and lower fees of the 403b. But you also seem happy with the professional management option with the 401k. I think you should consider leaving the 401k where it is, and being aggressive in funding the 403b. That will give you the best of both worlds.
elmer says
Theres an entity(what I will call it) that provides 401k to employees with both parties contributing for years. This entity stated it was loosing money and stopped their side of contributing to employees but were&still buying up properties and building new entities. Does this sound fraudulent to you & legal?
Jeff Rose says
Hi Elmer – If you’re describing your 401k, you need to consult with an attorney if you think that there may be fraudulent activity connected with the account. But if the fact that the entity stopped making matching contributions to the plan is your main concern, then they do have a right to do that. In fact, companies change their contributions all the time.
Jonathan Dyer says
Having never worked for a non-profit or the government I’ve never actually had a 403(b) but it sounds interesting. Good to know just in case!
[email protected] says
Love the employer match! I stayed with my employer longer than I wanted to so I could reach 5 magic years that guaranteed a match. That was a huge boost to my retirement savings.