You should treat the process of buying car insurance as seriously as buying the car itself. While the car protects you physically in an accident, your auto insurance policy protects you financially.
Nearly every state mandates a minimum amount of car insurance, but you shouldn’t apply that minimum and pick the lowest quote. Instead, most drivers should carry more than the state requirement, and from a company you can trust. Consider it the same as looking up the reliability and safety ratings before purchasing your vehicle.
In order to choose the best car insurance company for you, you’ll want to consider your unique needs and preferences and weigh factors like claims satisfaction, financial strength, and availability in your state.
IN THIS ARTICLE:
- The 10 best auto insurance companies of 2019
- Compare companies by state
- How to pick a policy
- Cost-saving tips and tricks
- Understand coverage options
Top 10 Best Auto Insurance Companies of 2019
| Company | Best For | J.D. Power Score, 2019 | A.M. Best Rating, 2019 | Consumer Reports Reader Score | Premiums Written ($bn) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Progressive | Discounts why? | 856 | A+ | 87 | $22.8 |
| Allstate Insurance | Overall User Experience why? | 853 | A+ | 88 | $21.4 |
| GEICO | Mobile App why? | 879 | A++ | N/A | $29.6 |
| Esurance | Personalized Policies why? | 844 | A+ | N/A | $1.68 |
| State Farm | Teen Drivers why? | 878 | A++ | 89 | $41.8 |
| Liberty Mutual | Premium Add-Ons why? | 857 | A | 88 | $11.6 |
| USAA | Military why? | 900 | A++ | 95 | $13.2 |
| Amica | Well Qualified Drivers why? | 898 | A+ | 94 | $2.3 |
| Auto-Owners Insurance | Customer Service why? | 870 | A+ | 93 | $7.58 |
| The Hartford | AARP Members why? | 873 | A+ | 90 | $15.8 |
Progressive
Progressive is the fourth-largest auto insurer in the U.S. and has consistently strong reviews. In fact, roughly 1 in 10 drivers in America has chosen Progressive above any other.
Where we consider them to really stand out, however, is in the widely available discounts. Between good student and homeowner discounts, the safe driver (up to 31%), pay-in-full, multi-car, their Name Your Price and Snapshot tools (which helps Progressive base your rate on your actual driving habits), almost everyone will qualify for at least one discount.
Need motorcycle coverage? Progressive tops our list for that too!
TO LEARN MORE:
Allstate Insurance
Allstate is a happy-medium company. They write a large number of premiums, have strong financials, receive praise from their customers, and have a good digital experience as well as brick and mortar offices and agents across the country.
Compared to a company like Geico, who prioritizes (and shines) at a technology-driven experience, Allstate gives you the option to interact via web or face-to-face locally with an agent.
We suggest Allstate particularly if you’re bundling policies, as they can be on the expensive side otherwise.
TO LEARN MORE:
GEICO
Who hasn’t heard of Geico? Their clever marketing is hard to miss: the charming gecko, “so easy a cavemen could do it”, and that Wednesday-loving camel.
But advertising aside, Geico really shines in their digital experience. If you’re a self-service, technology-over-agent type of shopper, then Geico’s mobile app is for you.
You can quote, buy and manage your insurance right from your phone. That means paying your bill, requesting roadside assistance, or submitting a claim. And with more than 1.7M reviews (more than their competitors, combined) in Apple’s App Store alone, averaging a 4.8-star rating, the experience is well-tested and well-endorsed.
TO LEARN MORE:
Esurance
Esurance was one of the first companies to start selling directly to the customer instead of going through an agent. To this day, they still do not have any local agents. But they offer a smooth digital experience that makes it easy to customize a plan, receive quotes, manage your policy and file claims.
Esurance received “better than most” marks across the board in 2019’s J.D. Power’s Auto Insurance Shopping Study.
One of the primary advantages of buying auto insurance through Esurance is that you have the control and flexibility to build a personalized policy, specific to your unique needs.
TO LEARN MORE:
State Farm
Founded in 1922, State Farm Insurance has a history of financial stability and customer service satisfaction. According to the Insurance Information Institute, State Farm is the largest provider of private passenger auto insurance, with more than $40b in premiums written.
Although State Farm offers online quotes and a mobile app, they’re differentiated by their ability to offer individual, personal service through their robust network of physical offices and caring agents.
So, unlike Geico and Esurance which target the technology-savvy, hands-off type of consumers, State Farm is perfect for those who would rather drive to a local office and have their questions answered and hands held through the process, without having to navigate an app or website.
State Farm also shines for households with teen drivers. While most companies charge notoriously high rates for this riskier demographic, State Farm offers both a good student discount and its Steer Clear feature. Steer Clear is an app-based program for drivers under 25, which tracks driving behavior and offers mini safety courses. After “graduating” from the program, drivers earn a substantial discount that lasts until they’re 25.
TO LEARN MORE:
Liberty Mutual
Founded in 1912, Liberty Mutual Insurance insures more than 1.5 million vehicles and has some of the top customer service ratings.
Liberty Mutual has more than 900 local offices, so they’re able to offer personalized service similar to State Farm.
They offer comparable standard coverage, as well as the option to add premium add-ons like:
- Accident forgiveness: Your insurance rates won’t go up when you’re involved in your first accident.
- New car replacement: If you total your car when it’s less than a year old and has fewer than 15,000 miles, they’ll reimburse you the cost of a new car, not just the depreciated value.
- Better car replacement: You’ll be reimbursed for a car that is one model year newer and 15,000 fewer miles than your totaled car.
- Deductible fund: Reduce your deductible by $100 when you add this feature, and then another $100 every year after that.
TO LEARN MORE:
USAA
If you’re fortunate enough to be a USAA member (members or former members of the United State military and their close family members), then USAA should be your first stop for auto insurance.
USAA received an “Among the Best” rating from J.D. Power’s Claims Satisfaction Survey, and “Better than Most” in every category of their Insurance Shopping Study.
They also offer extremely competitive rates, often cheaper than any of their competitors. According to a study done by U.S. News, USAA’s average rate nationally was $895 – more than 15% cheaper than the next company on their list.
TO LEARN MORE:
Amica Mutual
Amica Mutual is consistently rated as one of the best auto insurance companies, in industry awards and by their customers. In fact, they were at the top of this year’s J.D. Power Claims Satisfaction Survey.
Their policies include features that most of their competitors do not, such as no restrictions on your body shop choice as well as interior vehicle coverage.
While Amica Mutual is a great choice all-around, there are a couple of downsides.
First, some policy changes require a phone call, and their online resources can be lacking – both of which can be frustrating if you’re a self-service consumer.
Second, while they don’t have membership restrictions like USAA, they admit to being stringent about who they extend policies to. Generally, Amica says that drivers with high credit scores and at least three-years of clean driving history – that is, a record without violations, accidents or claims – are most likely to qualify.
TO LEARN MORE:
Auto-Owners Insurance
While Auto-Owners Insurance keeps a fairly low profile, they receive extremely high marks across the board. In fact, J.D. Power awarded it “Better than Most” in every category in its 2019 Insurance Shopping Study.
The fact that Auto-Owners Insurance has been around since 1916 should also put your mind at ease. During that time, they have consistently exhibited financial stability, with an “A+” rating from A.M. this year.
Auto-Owners Insurance operates on an agent-only model, favoring relationships and local business to faceless technology. In fact, they have 6,300 agents despite only being available in 26 states. So if you’re in one of those states, there are likely multiple offices for you to choose from in your city alone.
Auto-Owners Insurance operates in the following states: Alabama, Arizona, Arkansas, Colorado, Florida, Georgia, Idaho, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Kentucky, Michigan, Minnesota, Missouri, Nebraska, North Carolina, North Dakota, Ohio, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, South Dakota, Tennessee, Utah, Virginia, and Wisconsin.
TO LEARN MORE:
The Hartford
With more than 200 years of history in business, The Hartford has built an excellent reputation for customer service and claims processing.
Their car insurance caters specifically to AARP members, offering several features that uniquely accommodate this group:
- Lifetime Renewability Auto Insurance: Once you have an automobile insurance policy with The Hartford, your coverage will be renewed for as long as you’re able to drive.
- 12-Month Auto Insurance Rate Protection: Your premium is locked in for a full year, unlike most insurance policies which may change rates every six months.
- RecoverCare – Assistance After an Accident: Provides reimbursement after an accident for home services such as house cleaning, lawn maintenance, snow removal, meal prep, and even dog walking.
TO LEARN MORE:
Compare Best Auto Insurance Companies by State
Your experience with each car insurance company can vary widely depending on where you live. J.D. Power recognized this inconsistency and has started issuing region-specific recommendations in addition to their nationwide ratings.
According to J.D. Power, the highest-ranked auto insurance brands by region are:
- California: Esurance
- Central: Shelter
- Florida: Allstate
- Mid-Atlantic: Erie Insurance
- New England: Amica Mutual
- New York: New York Central Mutual
- North Central: Westfield
- Northwest: PEMCO Insurance
- Southeast: Farm Bureau Insurance—Tennessee
- Southwest: The Hartford
- Texas: Texas Farm Bureau
To compare companies based on their reputation in your state, use the map below.
How to Pick A Policy With the Best Auto Insurance Companies
Knowing which companies received the highest marks year after year is just part of the battle.
Beyond researching the best auto insurance companies on the market, you’ll also need to decide which type of policy to buy – and how much coverage you really need. On top of those factors, you’ll need to consider how high your deductible should be.
Consumer Reports offers an extremely helpful guide that highlights the steps you can take to find the best policy for your needs. Even if you’re fairly happy with your policy, they suggest shopping around to compare rates at least every two or three years.
That way, you have a good idea of where car insurance rates are headed and how much you could save if you switch. Plus, it never hurts to shop around. Based on your age, your driving record, and other factors, the policy you have now could be considerably cheaper if you switched firms.
When comparing companies, consider these tips:
1. Pick a top-rated insurer
Consumer Reports suggests reading through the most recent auto insurance claims and satisfaction studies to see which companies consistently come out on top.
By checking auto insurance ratings, you gain insight from each company’s existing customer base.
2. Set the right deductible
No matter whether you buy liability coverage or full coverage for your vehicle, you need to pick a deductible that meets your needs.
Consumer Reports suggests choosing a higher deductible if you want to save on monthly premiums but setting a lower deductible if you want to avoid a large out-of-pocket expense in the event of a car accident.
Their rule of thumb: “If you have a good driving record and haven’t had an at-fault accident in years, or ever, opting for a higher deductible on collision coverage might be a good bet.”
Just remember to keep that much cash on hand in case you need it!
3. Don’t buy state minimum coverage if you truly want a high-quality auto policy
While state minimum coverage is less expensive in the short-term, it can prove extremely costly if you have a claim that far exceeds the cap on the policy you purchased.
By investing in a policy that offers more generous coverage limits, you can save yourself some heartache and protect your personal property in the event of a costly accident.
4. Ask friends and family for recommendations
While reading auto insurance provider reviews and ratings is a smart move, you can also ask family and friends for their recommendations.
General ratings can help you gauge the quality of any company; however, personal reviews tend to hold more weight. Ask friends and family members whether they have had a good experience with their auto insurer before you purchase a policy.
You may be able to nail down the best insurer for your needs based on the suggestions of others.
5. Get quotes from multiple companies
If you’ve read plenty of insurance company reviews and still can’t decide, it might help to get several quotes to compare. Depending on where you live and other factors, one company could offer a much better deal on auto insurance than the rest.
In this scenario – where one company is much cheaper overall – you should figure out why the price is so affordable. Are you comparing apples to apples with the same levels of coverage and a similar deductible?
To help with this, we recommend QuoteWizard.com. They make it easy to compare quotes from the best car insurance companies head-to-head.
7 Cost-Saving Tips for Cheap Auto Insurance
While auto insurance rates are extremely competitive, they still vary widely depending on the company you use and the type of policy you purchase. With that being said, there are still plenty of ways to get the lowest rates possible.
Consider these 7 tips if you’re looking for cheap car insurance:
1. Ask about discounts
Some of the best car insurance companies offer discounts on anything from bundled policies to good credit, zero claims, theft protection devices, pay-in-full, and more.
The most significant discounts are often attached to electronically-measured assessments of your driving habits, which allows the company to base their rates on your actual tendencies behind the wheel. This is especially helpful for groups like teen drivers, who are seen as high-risk drivers (and have premiums to match!).
Allstate Insurance, for example, offers Drivewise – a discount program for customers who install a tracking device into their vehicle. By letting Allstate monitor your driving habits, you can qualify for a discount of up to 30 percent. State Farm offers “Steer Clear”, a similar program geared specifically for drivers under 25.
* As a quick rule of thumb, we’ve found Progressive to offer the most comprehensive discounts.
2. Drive less
Naturally, the less your vehicle is on the road, the less likely you are to have an accident. Car insurance companies recognize this, and many offer discounts or overall cheaper rates for low-mileage drivers.
So, if you work from home or have a short commute to work, make sure to mention it to your agent.
Even if you don’t naturally fall into one of those two groups, you could make yourself qualify by carpooling to work or opting for public transportation.
Each auto insurance company has their own limits for how many miles still qualify as “low mileage”, and they may require you to prove how much you drive each year.
The best way to find out if you qualify for a low mileage discount is to ask your auto insurance agent.
3. Shop around
Like I warned at the beginning of the article, buying car insurance should be a balance between price and value. Purchasing a cut-rate policy might get you legal on the road, but it will leave you in a bad (or catastrophic!) spot financially if you get in a wreck.
That said, once you’ve narrowed your options to reputable companies, you need to shop around. Auto insurance rates can easily vary by hundreds of dollars even with the same car and driver.
We recommend comparing at least 5 or 6 auto insurance firms.
Fortunately, the Internet makes shopping around super easy, with access to rates in minutes.
4. Consider raising your deductible
Whether you’re shopping around for a new auto insurance policy or planning to keep the one you have, raising your annual deductible is a smart way to save on your monthly premiums.
If you want a $500 deductible to access your auto coverage, your insurance will be more expensive than if you chose a $1,000 deductible from the start. To save money, you should choose the highest deductible you can reasonably afford to pay.
If you do choose to go with a higher deductible, make sure you keep enough cash on hand to cover it at any time.
If you have a $1,000 deductible on your auto policy, for example, you should set aside at least that much in an account – or make sure you keep enough cash to cover your deductible in your regular emergency fund.
5. Reduce coverage on older cars
While you might consider full coverage on your cars, that doesn’t mean you need it. Where full coverage is smart on newer cars, liability insurance coverage may be a smarter move for older, paid-off models.
To find your break-even point, check out how much your car is actually worth on a website like Kelley Blue Book.
If the cost of full coverage on your car is nearly as much as the car is worth itself, converting your policy to liability only can help you save money without jeopardizing your financial life.
6. Keep your credit in good shape
Most of the best auto insurance companies check your credit before they extend a new policy.
If your credit is excellent, this will only help you get the best auto insurance rates. If your credit is poor, on the other hand, you might be asked to pay a whole lot more.
To keep your credit in good health, check your credit score and report frequently.
While Credit Karma lets you see an estimate of your credit score for free at any time, AnnualCreditReport.com is a government-approved website that lets you see your full credit report from all three credit reporting agencies once per year for free.
7. Keep insurance costs in mind when you choose a car
The newer your car is, the more expensive your car insurance premiums will likely be. Also, consider the fact that some car models with expensive replacement parts can cost more to insure regardless of age.
Consumer Reports suggests asking your car dealer to show you the “Relative Collision Insurance Cost Information Booklet,” produced annually by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.
That way, you’ll be in the best position to avoid models with insurance costs that are higher than most.
Understand Coverage Options
With all of the different coverages, premium or specialized add-ons, and general industry jargon, putting together an overall insurance package that best protects you can be a hard task. You’ll want to consider your driving history, family, vehicle and any other special needs – without overpaying or under-insuring.
To help, here’s a quick rundown of the most common coverage options. Then you can work with an agent to personalize your policy further.
Liability insurance
This is what’s required by law in most states. It covers the other person’s expenses if you cause a car accident. There are two types of liability coverage: bodily injury and property damage. Bills to cover either of these can quickly run into the tens of thousands, so make sure you’re adequately covered here!
Personal injury protection (PIP)
Personal injury protection pays the medical bills for you and your passengers after an accident. It also extends to times when you’re a passenger in someone else’s car or if you’re hit by a car while walking or biking. PIP is similar to bodily injury liability insurance, except that the liability insurance covers the other driver’s medical expenses when you’re at fault, while PIP covers yours, regardless of whether you caused the accident or not.
Collision insurance
Collision insurance helps pay to repair or replace your vehicle after an accident. This can be damage caused by another car or an object, like a tree or fence. If you own your car outright (in other words, you aren’t leasing or making payments), this coverage is optional.
Comprehensive insurance
Reimburses for repair or replacement of your vehicle after an incident that’s not a collision. For example, comprehensive insurance kicks in for damage from vandalism, extreme weather (hail, falling trees, flood), fire or theft. Like collision insurance, comprehensive is optional unless required by your lienholder.
Uninsured/underinsured motorist insurance
Covers you in instances where the driver at fault doesn’t have car insurance, or at least doesn’t have enough of it. This type of insurance also helps in instances of hit-and-runs, assuming you file a police report.
Gap insurance
In the case of a total loss or theft, gap insurance will cover the difference between the amount your car is worth and the amount you still owe.
Roadside assistance
Covers things like flat tire changes, fuel and fluid deliveries, towing, or dead batteries. You should make sure you don’t have roadside assistance through any other program, like certain credit cards or the vehicle’s manufacturer, before paying for this add-on.
The Bottom Line
When shopping around for the best deal on auto insurance, it’s important to look at more than just premiums.
The best auto insurance companies should offer you more than just the cheapest price – they should receive good ratings from their existing customers, be strong financially, and able to cater to your needs and preferences. The same goes for life insurance, burial insurance and health insurance.
The best way to shop for auto insurance is to do your own research, using industry-recognized surveys like J.D. Power ratings, helpful articles like this one, and the first-hand experiences of your family and friends.
Once you’ve narrowed your pool to a handful of qualified companies, then rate shop to find the best deal.
Linda says
Very helpful info on car insurance companies.
Charnetta says
Do I have to call each Insurance Company separately for quotes/rates or is there a one stop shop/place where I can get quotes from all of the companies at once. Your article did not mention this valuable piece of information.
Jeff Rose says
Hi Charnetta – You can call each individually, or you can use Quote Wizard, which can connect you with them all. We’ve included a link to Quote Wizard in the article.
Ljackpat1958@aol.com says
Your site does me no good at all because it refused to accept my zip code as valid. We have lived in the home for 50 years and I know my zip code. It is 48322 yet you site keeps telling me to enter a valid zip code. 48322 is a valid zip code.
Patricia Low
David says
I know from experience some of these insurance companies are only out to steal your money like Geico and State Farm.
Dwayne Chatoney says
Please send your quotes via email. I will send a copy of the current insurance coverage I have for auto and home. I would like to bundle my policies and add a 1 ml umbrella policy.
Jeff Rose says
Hi Dwayne – We don’t offer auto insurance, but you can contact any of the companies on this list.
Lisa M Jones says
Looking for an affordable car insurance with full coverage
Jeff Rose says
Hi Lisa – Check with some of the ones on the this list. Rates differ between states with the same company so do plenty of shopping.
Titus Carerra says
Well, since I can hardly see any negative reviews on Progressive, and after all I’ve been hearing about it, I guess I’ll go for it then. 😉
Jeff Rose says
Hi Titus – If you dig deep enough you’ll find some. But that doens’t mean they’re a bad company. Every business has complaints against it, and unfortunately, people are more likely to complain than to praise. But yes, Progressive is an excellent company.
Eric says
I was with Liberty Mutual for about 15 years and was very satisfied with their prices and service, although I never filed a claim. When I retired and moved from California to Florida, my auto rate went up a ridiculous amount, to almost $10,000 a year even though I had no accidents and one minor moving violation in the last ten years. On top of that, Liberty Mutual screwed up my umbrella policy and told me it was “unenforceable,” whatever that means, but I had to pay for the policy anyway up to the time I canceled and switched to Progressive, which cost about one third the cost of Liberty Mutual for an identical policy. Even good companies change over time.
Jeff Rose says
Hi Eric – What you’ve seen is not an unusual situation. A company that’s good in one state isn’t in another. Liberty Mutual worked for you in California, but not in Florida. This is why it’s not possible to say one company is the best. That will vary by state and by your own personal profile. That’s why we produce these “10 Best” lists, to give you companies to investigate.
Selvin says
I can’t Believe you have GEICO last I just recently got in a Car accident on 3/16/18 and the claim process has been going really smooth and what people have told me my full coverage for two vehicles is the best they have seen.
Q says
Being in the business for a very long time, I have found that most people are clueless about insurance, even most agents who sell them. I will agree that their rates are cheap. But I wouldn’t recommend them. Inexperienced adjusters. They do not fully investigate. The policy does not cover like, kind, and quality which is bad if you have a new vehicle.
Jimbo says
STATEFARM worse company on the planet….dishonest, and does not do the right thing for there policyholders….
Screwing there policyholders is common practice for this insurance co.
Lou says
Liberty Mutual has raised my premium every year over the last 4 years, it went up 48 a month from last years to this year; I’ve had 0 accidents, tickets or claims.
They said it has gone up because live in Pennsylvania, really I’m paying for other bad drivers.
Switching to another insurance carrier.
Biraj Pokhrel says
Well this is a good article on best auto insurance companies this has helped me out to choose the one..
Cheers
Biraj pokhrel
Neel Opart says
Liberty Mutual just dropped my family because of two claims that were made on my daughters car. She had her car at school freshmen year and It was parked and hit on the rear corner closest to the road. It wasn’t her fault and no one came forward to admit to the accident. She no longer has a car at school, and drives rarely when she’s home. The second accident was when she was pulling out of the carport and her front bumper caught a wooden railing when she was backing out. That was her fault, but an accident. Isn’t that why we have insurance????? Before I got this letter from Liberty mutual, I sang their praises. I will loudly have bad things to say from now on. Don’t count on Liberty Mutual
Brandon Wilson says
I think this is a fair list, but I would have liked to see a few more insurance companies listed. I believe there are several more comparable insurance companies out there that could have made the list. We have partnered with several A+ rating carriers in Kansas and Missouri.
Richard Adachr says
BY far the worst and most expensive Insurance company is Intact Insurance. Worst experience ever trying to get payment after paying Insurance for 35 years and never having a claim! A disaster.
Bill from Ohio says
Comment on AARP Hartford ins. Under your rating for Hartford you state “•Only available to U.S. military members, veterans, or their close family members”
This is INCORRECT, that comment should be for USAA.
Now as to Hartford, I have had them for years and claims for uninured motorist on my car ins and for storm damage on my roof due to large hail. Both claims settled satisfactorily. Cost to the company will never be recovered thru cost of my policies. Also policy cost is in line with other large companies but defiantly not cheap. I just received a quote from Liberty Mutual on my car insurance $400 less that Hartford. However the agent seemed reluctant to send me the quote via email. I thought this strange since I wanted to verify the coverage was he same as I have, he said I just reviewed the coverage (via phone call) to which I replied I didn’t record the conversation so please send me an email detailing the cost and coverage, He stated he would but that was a couple hours age and still haven’ heard back. Go figure.
Ambreen Nisa says
HY,
Its my first visit to your blog and i have found it so useful and informative. I am also looking to get my car insurance and searching top companies that provides best services.Amazing list you have provided, i like USAA.
burpee says
USAA is great, but only for military families. For us “common folk”, it’s best to look around and see what is cheap in your area. Look at every website you find and get all the quotes you can. Eventually you’ll find some good rates that won’t break the back. I found 25/month (thru Insurance Panda) and I’m always looking for cheaper.
Also – I think there is no such thing as “customer loyalty” when it comes to auto insurance. If you’ve been with a company too long, chances are you are being screwed!
Mathew Burke says
I am glad to see USAA at the bottom; but it should not be on the list at all. I am currently going through a claim with them (total loss, I got rear ended, pushed into the car in front of me and they hit the car in front of them; not at fault). I have all correspondence recorded and proof of them lying to me, and using made up regulations to justify it. When asked for the reference for said regulations, I am ignored. I have been throwing WAC at them, quote after quote as to how they are being unruly. This was in December, it is now April and they have YET to give me a valuation report in compliance with WAC. I will be more than happy to provide a copy of our correspondence (with PII edited, obviously), proving how bad USAA is at customer service and how willing they are to break the rules if it benefits them. Email me if you want to see it. I finally had enough and contacted the Washington State Insurance Commissioner; USAA has until the middle of this month to respond to them… We will see what happens next.
I have been a USAA client for over 10yrs; I had never had issues with them before last year. This is just the breaking point, I’m transferring all of my accounts to other places. Do not use USAA… They are not the same as they once were.
mike says
Matthew thanks for posting this. You’re absolutely right. USAA has gone down the tubes, I dont get it, a simple claim recently for auto, turned into a nightmare. bouncing my calls all over the country with a bunch of idiots for claim reps answering the phones, and forcing my car into total loss when it should not have been, and paying only a portion of the damage even though I have collision.
Only thing I’m not sure of, is USAA used to be the cheapest, and they usually don’t penalize you too bad if you have claims, other companies, when I was younger, would hit me with heavy penalities or kick me off policy.
Maybe its time for me to shop around. not sure. I think since Hurricane Sandy, hit the east coast, all the insurance companies have probably put on their nasty hats. IMHO , their attitude at USAA started to change towards the end of my (very small minor damage), Sandy claims.
I can’t even figure out how to make a formal complaint up the corporate ladder at USAA. Still working on it.m
Molly Marine says
I beg to differ on USAA. I had been a loyal customer for over 15 years. My first claim on property went okay. It took them 4 months to pay out on lightening & they low balled me. (August will make a year on lightening)
Now flash forward present day. Last month I had a wreck. It was not my fault. I called USAA to get my rental covered because the cop wouldn’t give me the @ fault driver’s info said I had to wait for the police report. USAA informs me that I don’t have rental. Excuse me 3 months ago when I added collision I told you add rental & you said you would. USAA claims I did not tell them that, but I know I did because Roadside made it but not rental? Now mind you my Escalade is totalled. The frame is warped among many other things. I’m not @ fault & USAA (my own insurance company) tries to screw me? (The @ fault driver’s insurance company is someone I’ve never heard of but it’s not USAA) The adjustor says not totalled we’ll settle for 10Gs…. no I’m not settling for 10Gs on 50G+ truck especially with a warped frame NO WAY!! I’ve lost major retail value & nobody will buy it with the carfax that’s attached to it now.
My advice to everybody is this… if you’re in a wreck & you’re NOT @ fault GO GET A LAWYER. If you get the best one around to your local area – stats show you’ll get @ least 3x more than if you don’t have a competent lawyer or you Pro Se it. I’m not sue happy, but I’m not getting taken advantage of either.
USAA’s adjustor knew he messed up big time. He told me that & I said no I don’t agree & I’m not accepting that, so, I guess you need to finish this conversation with my lawyer. He promptly snarkily replied we can’t talk if you have a lawyer… I said I guess we can’t talk then here’s his number & hung up. I think he had enough time to Google my lawyer & he called me back to back 3x. The 3rd one I said you said we can’t talk so we’re not talking. You are finishing it with my lawyer… click. I’m done messing around @ this point. I hurt. I can’t get to my follow-up doctors appointments & they’re trying to screw me out of fair market value for my truck. Just no way.
BTW regarding the wreck- do NOT talk to the other insurance company- the @ fault driver’s insurance company. You’re not required if you have a lawyer. Get a lawyer!! Call them from the hospital if you have to they’ll come to you @ the hospital if you call them there. They’ll even come out to your house. Please don’t let the insurance company screw you. You just want what’s fair & your property covered fairly.
mike says
Molly, im curious how you get a lawyer to help on an auto damage-only claim, do you have to pay the lawyer by the hour, i mean if there’s no injuries, wish you could elaborate on this one.
Sarah Peterson says
I LOVE USAA! I am surprised it’s not higher on that list. I had Allstate and they never fought for me or my family even though we were paying more than we are paying now. Over where we are at, the speed limit for the highway is 70. There was hardly anyone on the road so my husband drive on the far left since there is a lot of exits in the far right lane. This woman pulled out in the far left lane doing 20. My husband didn’t have time to break because she pulled out right in from God us with no turn signal. But Always was already assuming it was his fault even though they can review the car to see how fast he was going and who was in the wrong. I am glad we dropped them and moved to USAA. They are the best!
Sarah Peterson says
Sorry there is a few typing errors. My phone didn’t show the bottom of where I was typing and my phone must have auto corrected a couple of these words.
MoneyAhoy says
I have had Progressive for years and have never had any trouble. My car got plowed into by a deer, and Progressive was reasonable to deal with. Their rates are also about the best I can find. We bundle in our home insurance (through some licensed third party) and save even more! Our rates just actually went down this past 6-month period which was a pleasant surprise.
Rachel says
I know I’m going to have to start looking at my auto-insurance options some time in the near future, so I am definitely going to have to do my research and, like you said, see what each company’s customer base says about their experience. Thanks providing this list and your advice!
Millennial Moola says
I’m pretty surprised that GEICO didn’t make the list. I’ve been really pleased with them ever since becoming a customer. That said, I’ve never had to file a claim, but my limited interaction with their non claim related customer service has been really good
Eldorado says
I have been a GEICO customer for about least 15 years. Claims and customer service are not the issue with them. After said years of faithfully paying my insurance on time and renewing each year I accidently back into a car in my driveway. The cars were repaired without incident. However, GEICO penalized me by taking away my good driver discount and increase my monthly insurance rate by nearly $100.00 ; leving a hefty penalty for making a claim. I can’t imagine the money they made off of me during the 15 years I’ve faithfully paid auto insurance. I am hunting for a new auto insurance carrier since GEICO obviously thinks driving is perfect and accidents never happen.
Mooseman says
Watch out for GEICO especially when changing coverages. I have learned the hard way that you can’t trust them to get your changes correct. I was just hit in the rear while stopped at a stop sign. I am trying to go through the collision coverage I am supposed to have only to have GEICO tell me that I removed this coverage a few months ago. The fact of the matter is I did not remove this coverage and never would have done that or agreed to that. Trying to reason with them has been an exercise in futility so far with a supervisor trying to put the onus on me for the problem. I am currently awaiting their final position on their review of this matter, but whatever the outcome I now know I cannot relie on them to get things right and I will always have to check on them. The mistakes they make hurt you, not them.
Stephen J hill says
I have been with Geico for 10 years, what kept me with them is that my daughter had just graduated high school and started college she asked to borrow the car because she was late for school, I said yes she got into a fender bender. Geico paid the claim and they even asked its my choice to add my daughter to my policy or not. Insurance only went up by $30 dollars a month.
I have 1 Full coverage, and 2 Liability vehicles with them and I pay $170 a month.
Jeff Rose says
Hi Stephen – I think you’re doing the right thing – as long as the premium continues to be reasonable compared to the competition. Even though we obsess on low rates, quality of service matters. It does little good if you get the cheapest policy, then they stick you when you have a claim. With must auto claims there’s going to be a human error factor (especially with new drivers), and you can’t be with companies that will hold that against you to such a degree that it seems like they no longer want your business.
Raham says
I have had GEICO for over 15 years, about 8 years in my rates skyrocketed never made a claim. An hour and fifteen minute call and GEICO found about $550 worth of discounts. 8 year later my daughter had an accident my rates went up 102%. A 102% increase does not fit my budget.