• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
Good Financial Cents®
Content is based on in-depth research & analysis. Opinions are our own. We may earn a commission when you click or make a purchase from links on our site. Learn more.
  • Make Money
    • Get Money Now
      • Ultimate Guide to Making Money
      • Need Money Now
      • Get Free Money Fast
      • Make Money Fast
      • Make $1K Per Month
      • Make $100 Per Day
    • Control Your Destiny
      • Self Employed Jobs
      • Make Money from Home
      • Hobbies That Make Money
      • How to Become a Freelance Writer
      • Small Business Ideas to Start
      • How to Become an Independent Contractor
      • Best Online Jobs
    • Passive Income
      • Passive Income Ideas
      • Multiple Streams of Income
      • Extra Income
      • Residual Income Ideas
      • Learn to Sell e-Books
      • Make Money on Facebook
      • Make Money on Tiktok
      • Best Online Survey Sites to Make Money
    • Explore More
      • Best Side Hustle Ideas
      • Make Money for Teens
      • Best Online Colleges
      • Best Jobs No College Degree
      • Become a Millionaire
      • Careers for the Future
  • Manage Money
    • Best Of
      • Budgeting Tools
      • Personal Finance Software
      • Best Cashback Cards
    • Company Reviews
      • Personal Capital vs Mint
      • Personal Capital Review
      • SmartAsset Review
    • Guides
      • Buy or Lease a Car
      • What is Liquid Net Worth?
      • Setting Financial Goals
      • How to Budget
      • Ways to Save Money
    • Explore More
      • How Much Car Can I Afford?
      • Best Auto Refinance Companies
  • Invest
    • Best Of
      • Best Short and Long-Term Investments
      • Best Low Risk Investments
      • Best Online Stock Brokers
      • Best Crypto Exchanges
      • Best Short Term Investments
      • Best Long Term Investments
      • Best Trading Platforms
      • Best Investment Apps
    • Company Reviews
      • Lending Club
      • Robinhood
      • M1 Finance
      • Ally
      • TD Ameritrade
      • Fundrise
      • Betterment
      • Etrade
      • Wealthfront
    • Guides
      • Investing for Beginners
      • Investing Small Amounts of Money
      • Investing in Real Estate
      • No Money Down Real Estate
      • Bonds vs Stocks
      • Peer to Peer Lending
      • Best Hedges Against Inflation
      • Safe Bitcoin Investing in 2023
    • Explore More
      • Bitcoin vs. Real Estate
      • Betterment vs Wealthfront
      • Investing for College Students
      • Stock Market Alternatives
    • By Investment Amount
      • How to Invest $100
      • How to Invest $1K
      • How to Invest $2k-$3k
      • How to Invest $5K
      • How to Invest $10K
      • How to Invest $15k
      • How to Invest $20K
      • How to Invest $30k
      • How to Invest $50K
      • How to Invest $100K
      • How to Invest $200K
      • How to Invest $500K
      • How to Invest $1M
  • Taxes
    • Best Of
      • Best Tax Relief Companies
      • Best Tax Software
    • Guides
      • Federal Income Tax Guide 2023
      • Taxes and Cryptocurrency
      • How to Do Your Own Taxes
      • How to Invest Your Tax Refund
      • Hiring a Professional Tax Preparer
      • Tax Tips for Freelancers
    • Company Reviews
      • TurboTax Review
      • H&R Block Review
      • Taxslayer
      • Tax Act
  • Insurance
    • Best Of
      • Best Life Insurance
      • Best Home Insurance
      • Best Auto Insurance
      • Cheap Term Life Insurance
      • Car Insurance For Young Adults
    • Guides
      • Term vs Whole Life
      • Different Types of Car Insurance
      • Average Cost of Car Insurance
    • Explore More
      • Life Insurance Over 50
      • Life Insurance Over 80
      • $1 Million Life Insurance
      • $2 Million Life Insurance
      • $3 Million Life Insurance
    • Company Reviews
      • Banner Life Insurance
      • Ladder Life Insurance
      • Health IQ
      • Haven Life
      • Policygenius
      • State Farm Auto Insurance Review
  • Retirement
    • Roth IRA
      • Best Places to Open a Roth IRA
      • Best Investments for Roth IRA
      • 7 Roth IRA Secrets
      • Roth IRA Conversion Guide
      • Roth IRA Rules
      • Roth IRA vs Roth 401k
      • Are Roth IRA Contributions Tax Deductible?
    • 401(k)
      • 401(k) Limits
      • 401(k) to Roth Rollover
      • Is 401(k) Enough for Retirement?
      • Maxed Out 401(k): What's next?
    • Traditional IRA
      • Traditional IRA Rules and Limits
      • Traditional IRA vs. 401(k)
      • Simple IRA Rules
      • SEP IRA Rules
      • How Much Do You Need to Start an IRA?
    • Explore More
      • SEP IRA vs. Roth IRA
      • 457 Plan for Successful Retirement
      • 401a Rollover Rules
      • How to Retire at 50
      • How to Retire at 55
  • Banking
    • Best Of
      • Best National Banks
      • Best High-Yield Savings Accounts
      • Best Checking Accounts
      • Best Savings Accounts
      • Best CD Rates
      • Best Money Market Accounts
    • Company Reviews
      • BBVA
      • Synchrony
      • Wells Fargo
    • Explore More
      • 9 Banking Alternatives for 2023
      • What is a Credit Union?
  • Home
    • Best Of
      • Best Mortgage Lenders
      • Best Mortgage Refinance Companies
      • Best Home Warranties
      • Best Homeowners Insurance
      • Best VA Loans
      • Best Mortgage Rates
      • Best Moving Companies
      • Best Home Security
    • Guides
      • Home Buying Checklist
      • Online Home Appraisal
      • How Much House Can I Afford?
      • First-time Homebuyer Programs
      • How to Get Approved for a Home Loan
      • Save Money When Building a House
      • How to Save for a Downpayment
      • When to Refinance Your Mortgage
    • Explore More
      • 15 vs. 30-year Mortgage
      • Home Warranty vs. Home Insurance
      • Veterans United Home Loan Review
      • Quicken Loans Review
      • HELOC vs Second Mortgage
      • DCU Mortgage Review
      • Costco Mortgage Program Review
      • USAA Mortgage Loan Review
  • Credit
    • Best Of
      • Best Credit Repair Companies
      • Best ID Theft Protection Services
      • Best Credit Report Options
      • Best Bad Credit Loans
    • Guides
      • How to Build Your Credit Score
      • How to Raise Your Credit Score in 5 Months
      • How to Dispute Your Credit Report
      • Hot to Remove Collections from Your Credit Reports
      • How Identity Theft Destroys Your Credit Score
    • Explore More
      • What is a Good Credit Score?
      • What is a Bad Credit Score?
  • Debt
    • Best Of
      • Best Debt Consolidation Loans
      • Best Personal Loans
      • Best Student Loans
      • Best Student Loan Refinance
    • Guides
      • What is Debt Consolidation?
      • How to Get Out of Debt
      • How to Get a Personal Loan Approved
      • How to Pay Off Student Loans Faster
      • Should I Consolidate My Debts?
      • Should I File for Bankruptcy?
    • Company Reviews
      • Credible
      • Sofi

Ask GFC 030: What Are My Options With a 457 Rollover?

https://www.goodfinancialcents.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/07/MG_5503-150x150.jpg
  • Written By:
    Jeff Rose, CFP®

    Jeff Rose, CFP®

    Jeff Rose, CFP® is a Certified Financial Planner™, founder of Good Financial Cents, and author of the personal finance...

    Read More
  • Updated: September 3, 2021
  • 6 Min Read
  • Advertising Disclosure

    Advertising Disclosure

    GoodFinancialCents® has an advertising relationship with the companies included on this page. All of our content is based on objective analysis, and the opinions are our own. For more information, please check out our full disclaimer and complete list of partners.

Quality Verified THE GFC® PROMISE
shield check icon
Quality Verified

GoodFinancialCents® partners with outside experts to ensure we are providing accurate financial content.

These reviewers are industry leaders and professional writers who regularly contribute to reputable publications such as the Wall Street Journal and The New York Times.

Our expert reviewers review our articles and recommend changes to ensure we are upholding our high standards for accuracy and professionalism.

Our expert reviewers hold advanced degrees and certifications and have years of experience with personal finances, retirement planning and investments.

shield check icon
Why You Can Trust GoodFinancialCents®

GoodFinancialCents® partners with outside experts to ensure we are providing accurate financial content.

These reviewers are industry leaders and professional writers who regularly contribute to reputable publications such as the Wall Street Journal and The New York Times.

Our expert reviewers review our articles and recommend changes to ensure we are upholding our high standards for accuracy and professionalism.

Our expert reviewers hold advanced degrees and certifications and have years of experience with personal finances, retirement planning and investments.

There’s a lot written all over the web and elsewhere about what to do with retirement plan rollovers, like 401(k) plans, 403(b) plans and even IRAs.

But rarely discussed is what to do with a 457 rollover. As luck would have it, we received just such a question on Ask GFC:

Can a distribution ($50,000) from a 457 plan be “rolled over” into an existing Roth IRA that is over 5 years old? Is there any time limit before that money could be withdrawn? I realize taxes will need to be paid, but are there any other restrictions?

The reader asks about what to do with a 457 rollover, and mainly as it might relate to a rollover/conversion into a Roth IRA. I’m going to get into the Roth IRA conversion aspect, but I’m thinking to go a bit broader, and also cover a 457 rollover into a traditional IRA.

There are actually some situations where doing a 457 rollover – or any other employer sponsored retirement plan – sometimes makes more sense with a traditional IRA rather than a Roth IRA.

For those who aren’t familiar with a 457 plan, it’s identical to both 401(k) and 403(b) plans in most respects.

The main difference is that it’s a retirement plan offered by state and local governments, and some tax-exempt organizations. But the rollover considerations are also very similar to what they are for 401(k) and 403(b).

Can a 457 Rollover Be Made Into a an Existing Roth IRA?

In a word, absolutely! The options for a 457 rollover are the same as they are for other types of retirement plans. You can do a 457 rollover into a Roth IRA, which of course means that you are doing a Roth conversion.

Just as you would with any type of Roth conversion, any portion of the 457 rollover balance that is comprised of either tax-deferred contributions or investment income earned in the plan, will be subject to ordinary income tax upon conversion.

However, there is no 10% early withdrawal penalty on the rollover amount, even if you are under age 59 1/2 at the time of the conversion.

Whenever you do a Roth IRA conversion, you’re trading a tax liability now for for tax-free income later.

Once you reach age 59 1/2, and as long as the Roth IRA has been established for at least five years, any distributions taken are completely tax free.

There’s one other important benefit to the Roth IRA. They do not require that you begin taking Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs) from the plan at age 70 1/2. Virtually every other tax sheltered retirement plan does require RMDs. But if you have a Roth IRA, you can literally keep the money in the plan for the rest of your life.

That reduces the possibility you might outlive your money, but also means you’ll have more money to leave to your heirs at the time of your death.

It’s an excellent plan, so it’s easy to understand why the Ask GFC reader is asking about it as a potential destination for his 457 rollover.

Limits on Withdrawals of Roth Conversion Funds

The Ask GFC reader asks if there is any time limit before the conversion balance can be withdrawn. Since he references that the 457 rollover balance will be rolled over – actually converted – into an existing Roth IRA that is over five years old, he’s really asking if he will have access to the funds immediately, based on the fact his Roth account has met the the five year rule.

But the answer is no.

The five year old account will benefit him for ongoing direct Roth IRA contributions. He can withdraw the amount of those direct contributions since the account itself has met the five year limit. But that doesn’t apply on Roth IRA conversions.

According to IRS regulations, each Roth conversion resets the clock for another five year limit. That is, if he converts the funds from the 457 rollover to a Roth IRA now, he will have to pay the 10% early withdrawal penalty on the amount withdrawn until at least five tax years have passed since the conversion (the exception is if he is already over age 59 1/2).

Further, he will have to pay both the penalty and ordinary income tax on any amount of the withdrawals from the Roth IRA that represent investment income.

But just remember, we’re talking strictly about the 457 rollover/Roth conversion balance here, not his existing Roth IRA account, or any subsequent direct Roth IRA contributions.

Plan B: 457 Rollover into a Traditional IRA

The reader didn’t ask this question, but it’s a consideration that needs to be discussed in regard to a 457 rollover. The reader doesn’t give us any background information, such as his age, whether or not he is working, or what tax bracket he’s in. Those are all relevant considerations for any type of rollover, but especially if the rollover might involve a Roth IRA conversion.

The advantage to doing a 457 rollover into a traditional IRA is the rollover can be accomplished with no income tax liability or penalty.

The funds can remain in the IRA, building more investment income on a tax-deferred basis, and growing until age 59 1/2, when you can begin taking distributions, free from the early withdrawal penalty.

The disadvantage of doing the 457 rollover into a traditional IRA is when the distributions are taken, they will be subject to ordinary income tax.

Unlike the Roth IRA conversion, which forces you to pay the tax on the distribution now in exchange for tax-free withdrawals later, the rollover into the traditional IRA avoids taxes now, but requires them upon withdrawal. (A traditional IRA, unlike a Roth IRA, is also subject to RMDs beginning at age 70 1/2.)

But even without the tax-free distributions in retirement, doing the 457 rollover into a traditional IRA might still make more sense than doing a Roth conversion.

Traditional or Roth IRA – Which is the Better Route for a 457 Rollover?

The answer to this question really depends on the information the Ask GFC reader didn’t provide – his age, employment status and income tax bracket. For that reason, I’m going to keep this part of the discussion very general. Even though we don’t have the reader’s background circumstances, there are still important factors to consider anytime you do a rollover of any sort.

A Roth conversion generally makes more sense if you are in a lower income tax bracket. For example, if your combined federal and state marginal tax rate is 20%, the tax bite on the reader’s $50,000 457 rollover would be $10,000 ($50,000 X 20%). A Roth conversion will make a lot of sense if the reader expects to be in a similar or higher tax bracket during retirement.

However, if the reader has a combined federal and state marginal tax rate of 40%, the 457 rollover will result in a $20,000 tax ($50,000 X 20%). It also has to be considered that adding $50,000 to the reader’s income could easily push him into a higher tax bracket. That’s because the amount of the 457 rollover will be added to his other taxable income in the event he does a Roth conversion.

Now if the reader expects to be in a lower tax bracket during retirement, say 20%, the Roth conversion may not make as much sense. That’s because he will be incurring a 40% tax liability now, in exchange for a 20% tax break later.

If the reader is say, 35 years old, it might still be worth doing a Roth conversion. Even with the 40% tax, the account will have 25 to 30 years to grow through investment earnings. But if on the other hand, he is say, 55, doing the conversion now won’t leave much time to grow the account before retirement.

Strategy to Consider: Delayed Roth Conversion

We still don’t know the specifics of the reader’s background situation, but here is a suggestion that might incorporate both a traditional IRA and the Roth conversion.

If the reader is primarily interested in moving his money from an employer directed 457 plan into a self-directed IRA, he can do that by moving the money into a traditional IRA, if his marginal income tax rate would make a Roth conversion particularly costly.

By doing the 457 rollover into a traditional IRA, the reader avoids creating a tax liability related to the rollover. But that doesn’t completely remove the Roth conversion from consideration.

He can do the 457 rollover into a traditional IRA now, and then do a Roth conversion – from the traditional IRA to a Roth IRA – when he reaches retirement. If his income will drop in retirement, resulting in a lower marginal tax bracket, it may make more sense to do a Roth IRA conversion at that time.

He will still have to pay ordinary income tax on the amount of the conversion. But as long as he is at least 59 1/2 years old, he can withdraw the amount of the conversion free from tax and the early withdrawal penalty. He’ll then have to wait a minimum of five years to begin withdrawing the portion of the Roth IRA that represents investment income.

But that would give him access to the Roth IRA funds in retirement, with the ability to withdraw tax-free income.

Facebook LinkedIn Twitter

About the Author

Jeff Rose, CFP® is a Certified Financial Planner™, founder of Good Financial Cents, and author of the personal finance book Soldier of Finance. He was a financial planner for 16+ years having founded, Alliance Wealth Management, a SEC Registered Investment Advisory firm, before selling it to focus on his passion - educating the masses on the importance of financial freedom through this blog, his podcast, and YouTube channel.


Jeff holds a Bachelors in Science in Finance and minor in Accounting from Southern Illinois University - Carbondale. In addition to his CFP® designation, he also earned the marks of AAMS® - Accredited Asset Management Specialist - and CRPC® - Chartered Retirement Planning Counselor.

While a practicing financial advisor, Jeff was named to Investopedia's distinguished list of Top 100 advisors (as high as #6) multiple times and CNBC's Digital Advisory Council.

Jeff is an Iraqi combat veteran and served 9 years in the Army National Guard. His work is regularly featured in Forbes, Business Insider, Inc.com and Entrepreneur.

Facebook Twitter LinkedIn

You Might Also Enjoy

What Is The SIPC and How Does it Protect Your Investments?

What Is The SIPC and How Does it Protect Your Investments?

What Happens When Your Bank is Seized by the FDIC?

What Happens When Your Bank is Seized by the FDIC?

How to Invest $200,000 and Generate a Solid Return

How to Invest $200,000 and Generate a Solid Return

Webull Review: Trade Crypto and Traditional Investments on the Same App

Webull Review: Trade Crypto and Traditional Investments on the Same App

How To Diversify Your Portfolio With Artwork In 2023

How To Diversify Your Portfolio With Artwork In 2023

10 Best Investment Companies in 2023

10 Best Investment Companies in 2023

One Response

  1. Zach October 15, 2019

    I think you mean $50,000 x 40% as an example of paying $20k in taxes, not 20%.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Cancel reply

  • Make Money
  • Manage Money
  • Invest
  • Taxes
  • Insurance
  • Retirement
  • Banking
  • Home
  • Credit
  • Debt
  • About
  • Contact
  • Facebook LinkedIn Twitter

© 2023 Good Financial Cents®. All Rights Reserved. | Privacy Policy | Disclaimer

All written content on this site is for information purposes only. Opinions expressed herein are solely those of AWM, unless otherwise specifically cited. Material presented is believed to be from reliable sources and no representations are made by our firm as to another parties’ informational accuracy or completeness. All information or ideas provided should be discussed in detail with an advisor, accountant or legal counsel prior to implementation.

All third party trademarks, including logos and icons, referenced in this website, are the property of their respective owners. Unless otherwise indicated, the use of third party trademarks herein does not imply or indicate any relationship, sponsorship, or endorsement between Good Financial Cents® and the owners of those trademarks. Any reference in this website to third party trademarks is to identify the corresponding third party goods and/or services.