Shopping for an extended car warranty may not sound very fun, but having this protection can provide considerable peace of mind. After all, the best-extended car warranties can ensure your car gets fixed during a covered breakdown. Best of all, your extended warranty coverage will actually pay for the repairs.
But, which extended car warranty company should you purchase coverage from? Because there are quite a few reputable providers in this space, it’s crucial to compare them based on the warranty coverage they offer, their ratings and reviews, and the perks they offer customers.
While we believe Endurance may offer the best-extended warranties out there, we went on to compare the top six companies in this space. If you’re in the market for the best-extended car warranty money can buy, read on to learn more.
Most Important Factors for Extended Car Warranties
- While price is a major consideration when comparing extended car warranties, you’ll also need to consider the coverage you’re buying and how it compares to other providers. For example, some extended car warranties offer nearly bumper-to-bumper coverage with maintenance included, whereas others only cover certain components of your vehicle.
- As you compare extended car warranties, you should note that some require waiting periods before you can use your coverage. Make sure you know your plan’s waiting period before you move forward.
- While extended car warranty companies let you enter your information to get a free quote online, you usually need to speak with a customer service agent to get pricing for available plans.
- As you compare extended car warranties, make sure you price out coverage plans from at least three or four providers. Doing so is the best way to ensure you get quality protection for a price you can afford.
The Best Extended Car Warranties of 2023
4.4 out of 5 stars
Six plans
4.0 out of 5 stars
Five plans
3.2 out of 5 stars0
Five plans
4.0 out of 5 stars
Four plans
4.3 out of 5 stars
Three plans
N/A
Fourteen plans
Endurance
Endurance is one of the largest providers of vehicle service contracts in the United States, and they are backed by an AM Best “A” rated insurance company. This means you can rest assured your extended car warranty will cover claims as they arise, and that you’ll have protection against the costs and stress that typically come with auto breakdowns and other failures.
One major benefit of Endurance is the fact they’re a direct provider of their extended warranty coverage. This means you’ll purchase your plan from Endurance, and that they will manage your coverage from quote to claim.
Endurance also has a large selection of coverage plans to choose from, including six different plans that range from basic to their top tier Advantage plan with maintenance included.
- Direct provider with no middleman
- Large choice of plans available
- Available for most vehicles up to 20 model years and with up to 200,000 miles
- 30-day unconditional money-back guarantee
- Not accredited with the BBB
- You have to speak with an agent to get a quote
Select Auto Protect
Select Auto Protect has been in operation for over 30 years, and they offer a range of extended car warranty plans that can be used at any ASE-certified repair facility. They offer three main extended warranty plans to choose from — Silver, Gold, and Platinum. Where the basic Silver plan provides coverage for basic vehicle components like your transmission and brake system, Platinum coverage offers more robust protection for more components including your heat system, fuel system, and front and back suspension.
One major benefit of Select Auto-Protect is the fact they cover cars of any age, make, or model. This means you can use this provider for older cars you own or for classic cars, and regardless of your vehicle’s mileage.
- 30-day money-back guarantee
- 24/7 claims
- Use any ASE-certified facility
- Payment plans available
- Unlimited service calls
- Covers any car make, model, and mileage
- Fewer plans to choose from
- You have to speak with an agent to get a free quote
- Not accredited with the BBB
CarShield
CarShield was originally founded in 2005, and the company has become a major provider of extended car warranties since then. In addition to offering five different extended warranty plans for eligible vehicles, they also offer extended warranty protection specifically for motorcycles and ATVs.
CarShield offers five main extended car warranty plans for cars, which range from a basic “Aluminum” plan to “Diamond” coverage. Where the most basic coverage options only protect some components of your vehicle, Diamond coverage works similarly to the bumper-to-bumper coverage that comes with a new car.
- Customize your plan to your needs
- Towing and rental coverage included
- Repairs take place at any ASE-certified facility
- 24-hour roadside assistance
- Payment plans available
- You have to speak with an agent to get a free quote
- Not accredited with the BBB
Complete Car Warranty
Complete Car Warranty was only established in 2019, so there are few places to find user testimonials or reviews about the company online. However, we chose them for our ranking based on the fact their plans are highly customizable. For starters, Complete Car Warranty offers five different levels of CarGuard coverage ranging from Powertrain (basic protection) to robust Platinum coverage. However, the provider also offers more plans to choose from within their Matrix and Royal levels.
Each tier of coverage comes with a unique set of covered components, so you can customize your warranty coverage to your exact needs. All plans also come with roadside assistance, and you can have your car repaired at any certified vehicle mechanic nationwide.
- Most plans to choose from
- Coverage comes with roadside assistance
- Protection for all makes and models
- Available in all 50 states
- Just established in 2019 (short company history)
- You have to speak with an agent to get a free quote
- Not accredited with the BBB
Carchex
CarChex has been in operation since 2003, and the company added extended car warranties to their portfolio of offerings in 2004. Since then, the company has grown to become one of the most trusted extended warranty providers in the United States. They are one of the few companies in this space who is accredited by the Better Business Bureau (BBB), where they also boast an A+ rating.
CarChex offers five levels of extended warranty coverage for shoppers to choose from, ranging from basic Bronze protection all the way up to comprehensive Titanium coverage. Their plans also come with the largest selection of covered benefits, which include towing, rental car coverage, gas delivery, trip interruption insurance, and more.
- Most covered benefits included
- Payment plans available
- Choose your repair facility
- 30-day money-back guarantee
- Accredited with the BBB
- You have to speak with an agent to get a free quote
Autopom!
Autopom! is another extended car warranty provider who has an A+ rating with the BBB. This company also offers a wide range of warranty plans with plenty of included benefits. For example, customers get a 30 to 60-day money back guarantee, 24 hour roadside assistance and trip interruption reimbursement coverage as standard benefits.
When it comes to the extended warranty coverage this company offers, consumers have four main plans to choose from. Options include Powertrain Plus coverage that protects only the main components of your car all the way up to Exclusionary coverage which is closer to a new car warranty coverage. Most of their plans provide the option to tailor your warranty to your needs.
- Choose your own repair shop
- 30 to 60-day money-back guarantee
- Nationwide protection
- 24-hour roadside assistance and trip interruption coverage included
- Payment plans available
- Plans come with rental assistance
- Accredited with the BBB
- Fewer plans to choose from
- Must speak to an agent to get a free quote
- Eligibility for coverage varies by the vehicle's year, make, model, mileage, and state of residence
Other Companies We Considered
There are so many extended warranty providers offering plans today that it was hard to select the options for our ranking. The following companies barely missed the cut.
ForeverCar
ForeverCar is an extended car warranty provider that has been in operation since 2015. They offer four levels of extended warranty coverage with included benefits like rental car coverage, 24-7 roadside assistance, and travel expense reimbursement.
- Online chat feature available
- 30-day money back guarantee
- Only for vehicles with less than 150,000 miles
- Doesn't cover vehicle models older than 2010
- Prices and plans are locked in for 36 months
Olive
Olive was considered for our ranking based on the fact they are one of the only providers that lets you get a free online quote for extended warranty coverage without speaking to an agent. However, this provider only has three plans to choose from. They also just launched in 2020, so there aren’t many user testimonials or reviews to compare.
- Online quote process
- A+ rating with the BBB
- Only three coverage plans to choose from
- Just founded in 2020
How We Found the Best Extended Car Warranties
The extended car warranty companies that made our ranking were found to be “best” among all providers in this space. While some of our analysis was subjective, we compared each company and selected them based on the following attributes.
Multiple Plans
While some of the extended auto warranty companies we included in our ranking offer more plans than others, we only selected providers who have at least three tiers of extended warranty coverage to choose from. We also looked for companies that offer ways to customize your plan to your needs, whether with additional add-on coverage or a more robust selection of benefits.
Choose Your Own Repair Shop
We only selected companies that let you get your car fixed at a large selection of auto repair shops. Generally speaking, the providers for our ranking allow repairs at all ASE-certified repair shops or with any certified mechanic.
Money-Back Guarantees
Most of the companies on our list offer a 30-day or 60-day money-back guarantee.
Included Benefits
We also looked for extended car warranties that come with included benefits consumers can benefit from. Perks we looked for include roadside assistance, trip interruption insurance, gas delivery, rental car coverage, and more.
What You Need to Know About Extended Car Warranties
As you compare extended car warranties, there are several factors you need to consider that may be buried in the fine print. Details to look for in your plan include:
- Waiting Periods: Most extended car warranties have a waiting period that applies before you can use your coverage. Make sure you know about the waiting period you’re dealing with, as well as how waiting periods compare across providers.
- Deductibles: You will typically need to pay a deductible to file a claim with your extended warranty company. Make sure the deductible you choose is one you can easily afford.
- Vehicle Limitations: Some vehicle makes and models may not qualify for extended warranty coverage with certain providers.
- Length of Coverage: Finally, note that many companies offer limited coverage for a specific timeline (i.e. 36 months or three years). Make sure you know about potential limitations and what happens next.
- Not Car Insurance: A common misconception is that auto warranties and insurance are the same things. That is not correct. To find out more about auto insurance, see our best auto insurance companies.
The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) also lists some specific “gotchas” to watch out for when choosing an extended car warranty. For example, they point out that few auto service contracts cover all repairs and maintenance, and that you should watch out for exclusions and other fine print in your plans.
They also note that service contracts often limit how much they’ll pay for towing or related rental car expenses.
